Lester Mazor, one of the founding teachers at Hampshire College, came across as lively and sharp, even “revolutionary,” one person who came under his instruction said.

At the Amherst, Mass., campus, the charismatic professor taught law and legal philosophy. He also crossed lines.

According to an announcement from the college last week, an internal investigation concluded that he had acted inappropriately toward a female student four decades ago.

But the school’s response to the misconduct involves a complication: The professor is dead. Mazor, who taught at Hampshire from its founding in 1970 until 2007, died in 2011.

“Lester was one of the chief influences in my choosing a legal career,” Sigmund Roos, chair of the college’s board of trustees at the time, said in an obituary. “He was really an amazing teacher, and someone who even as he was teaching was always learning.”

That tribute now stands at odds with the stance of the board of trustees, which had to decide this semester what to do with the legacy of a man unable to answer the accusations against him. College leaders have issued a formal apology to the alumna who came forward recently to complain of “inappropriate behavior in the 1970s,” according to a letter from Hampshire’s president, Miriam Nelson, which was addressed to the college community last week. Its subject was “Historical Harassment.”

Investigating ‘historical’ complaints of harassment

An inquest by the college, Nelson wrote, “concluded that more likely than not the inappropriate behavior occurred.” The letter did not describe the nature of the alleged offense, but a September report from a committee on “Historical Complaints of Sexual Harassment” said its work began after the college’s former president, Jonathan Lash, who stepped down in June of this year, received a complaint from a graduate about decades-old “harassment” by a faculty member. She had gone to college representatives in the years since she left Hampshire, “but as far as she was aware there had been no follow-up on her complaint,” states the report, which does not name Mazor.

The college concluded that the alumna may not have been alone.

“During the investigation the College heard other allegations of inappropriate behavior, suggesting that this was not an isolated incident,” wrote Nelson, who co-signed last week’s letter with a vice president for academic affairs and dean of faculty, Eva Rueschmann.

Trustees met to review the findings and chose to apologize to the alumna.

“We recognize how difficult it is to revisit painful occurrences, and we respect our alumna’s courage in coming forward to share them,” the letter stated.

Grappling with the professor’s legacy

The more vexing question was what to do with the professor’s legacy — with the room on campus named for him, as well as the fund endowed in his name.

“Professor Mazor,” the administrators wrote, “cannot defend himself.” What’s more, they said, “these actions date from decades ago.”

Nevertheless, the college chose to remove Mazor’s name from the room and the fund created in his memory.

While some “may call into question the College’s actions,” the administrators wrote, the liberal arts college could leave no doubt about where it stood on issues of harassment brought to light by the #MeToo movement. Even, they suggested, when the light exposed someone who was no longer living.

“This era has brought long-needed attention to issues of sexual harassment and we want there to be no confusion at Hampshire over what behaviors were and are inappropriate,” the administrators affirmed. “We take our roles as educators, mentors, and role models very seriously and apologize that a member of our faculty apparently did not do so, regardless of the era.”

They added that the college was in the process of updating its policies on sexual harassment to account for this novel circumstance.

A pattern of impropriety

An article in the Daily Hampshire Gazette documented the controversy, seven years after an obituary for Mazor had appeared in its pages. The item from 2011 noted that Mazor had died peacefully in Berlin, where he had moved after retiring in 2007.

The professor was born in Chicago and grew up in Oakland, Calif. He studied history at Stanford University and then attended its law school. Mazor clerked on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit for Warren E. Burger, later chief justice of the U.S. Supreme Court. In 1962, Mazor became “the youngest law professor in the nation,” according to his obituary, when he joined the faculty at the University of Utah in his mid-20s. Eight years later, he moved to Amherst to begin teaching at Hampshire. He also established the college’s program in Berlin.

A tribute by a former student on the occasion of Mazor’s death testified to the professor’s charisma, but also included hints of a sometimes-overbearing personality. The student wrote of the “enigmatic psychic space” inhabited by the professor, which “made it hard to tell what he really thought.” The eulogy called him “revolutionary” but also “calm and sometimes paternal.”

The college’s review has now found that at the same time that he was captivating students, he was developing a pattern of improper behavior. While his offenses weren’t disclosed, Hampshire’s policy on sexual misconduct forbids a range of behaviors, from sexual assault to gender-based harassment and stalking. The college “strongly discourages” romantic relationships between faculty and students, though only expressly forbids them if there is a supervisory dimension.

The September report urged college leaders to considering prohibiting such relationships, or at least “to make the risks and responsibilities more explicit.”

Evolving policies

The liberal arts college amended its policies in February of this year after three years under review by the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights. Many colleges and universities have come under scrutiny in recent years related to compliance with Title IX, the federal civil rights law that bars gender discrimination in education programs that receive government money.

“I want to recognize the #MeToo movement for bringing to light the experiences of millions who have been subjected to inappropriate and illegal behaviors that occurred in the past, mostly from individuals who were in a position of power or influence over their careers,” wrote Lash, the college president at the time, in announcing the changes. “I salute the bravery of those who are speaking out. They will change our culture for the better.”

How New York Times reporters Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey broke the Harvey Weinstein story that sparked #MeToo

‘She Said,’ a new book from Kantor and Twohey, is an instant classic of investigative journalism

Mark Halperin harassed women. So why should he be the one to cover 2020?

Is this the best man to offer cogent analysis on what it means to have a field of female candidates?

Olympic figure skater Ashley Wagner says she was sexually assaulted at 17 by skater John Coughlin

She is the highest-profile skater to make a public allegation of sexual assault and the second top skater to publicly accuse Coughlin