The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

A female journalist wanted to profile a candidate for governor. He told her she had to be accompanied by a male colleague.

Citing ‘the optics’ of being alone with reporter Larrison Campbell, Mississippi state Rep. Robert Foster denied the request

By
July 11, 2019 at 1:53 p.m. EDT

Adapted from a story by The Washington Post’s Deanna Paul.

With the Mississippi Republican primary for governor approaching, Mississippi Today planned the outlet’s coverage, which included shadowing each of the three Republican candidates. Those candidates are Lt. Gov. Tate Reeves, former state Supreme Court chief justice Bill Waller Jr. and state Rep. Robert Foster. There are also eight Democrats running.

Mississippi Today reporter Larrison Campbell set out to cover Foster’s candidacy she requested to report on a 15-hour ride-along on the campaign trail. But that request was denied.

Before announcing his campaign to become Mississippi’s governor, Foster made a commitment to his wife, Heather. He’d follow the “Billy Graham rule” — which, in his words, means avoiding “any situation that may evoke suspicion or compromise of our marriage.”

This personal policy, which is also used by Vice President Pence, presented a problem for Campbell. Citing “the optics,” Foster declined Campbell’s request, unless she brought a male colleague. Campbell and her editor objected on the grounds that it was sexist, and it prevented her from completing a story assignment about the Republican contenders for governor.

Democrat Amy McGrath announces bid to oust Mitch McConnell in Kentucky

Campbell’s connection to Foster dated from November, when she received a tip that he planned to join the governor’s race. After breaking the story, Campbell said, she has kept an eye on Foster — calling him an “interesting” candidate: a Hernando, Miss., native “running to the right of a very conservative lieutenant governor,” but who also holds some more liberal views, like expanding Medicaid coverage.

Mississippi Today reporter Adam Ganucheau shadowed Reeves and Waller. Campbell, having interacted with Foster and his team on several occasions, said she proposed to ride along with him.

Campbell said Colton Robison, Foster’s campaign director, told her on Sunday the team was excited about the coverage and had a “big day planned Thursday.” The freshman representative would be driving to the Gulf Coast, giving Campbell access to a 15-hour day.

They discussed details, then Robison said he had “a weird request.”

Campbell recalled not knowing how to respond; she later broached it with her male editor, R.L. Nave, who said: “Absolutely not. That’s sexist.”

Two days later, Campbell suggested some ways Robison could assuage Foster’s concerns: She would keep her press pass in plain view; she would stick by Robison’s, not Foster’s, side. She reminded Robison that there would also be photographers with the team throughout the day.

“We’re really concerned about bad publicity,” she said he responded. “Some tracker could take a photo putting [Foster] in a compromising position, and it would jeopardize his campaign.”

Campbell recalled feeling “surprised and disappointed” during the call and said she asked Robison whether “the only reason I would be improperly linked to your candidate is that I’m a woman.”

Foster told The Washington Post on Wednesday in an email that he would grant Campbell the interview, but “we just want it to be in an appropriate and professional setting that wouldn’t provide opportunities for us to be alone.”

In what Campbell calls “a funny little twist,” she told The Post she is “very openly gay.”

In a phone interview Wednesday, Foster said people should always uphold a level of respect and professionalism and make sure there is no opportunity for there to be a he-said, she-said moment.

He added, “Everyone has to make their own decisions about how to act in life. This is mine.”

Following the phone conversation, Foster tweeted: “Typical liberal Washington Post is now criticizing me for my Christian beliefs. Not surprising, considering they are totally out of touch with America.”

On Tuesday, the Mississippi Today reporter published a piece detailing what had happened. Many responses Campbell received mention the #MeToo era, in which Foster is “trying to protect himself.” Some drew parallels to a doctor bringing a nurse into an examination room.

She was the first openly transgender person to address the DNC. Now she’s running for Delaware state Senate.

“That’s a fair point,” Campbell told The Post, “but the nurse is on the doctor’s payroll. If the doctor feels he needs to be protected, he doesn’t put the onus on the patient.”

Foster, she explained, has essentially said, “‘You can’t do this because you’re a woman and you’re responsible for making me feel comfortable.’ The problem is the notion that the woman carries the burden to make the man feel comfortable.”

A spokesperson for Waller, one of the other Republican contenders, said it would be a nonissue for his candidate. “It’s our campaign’s standard practice to always have a member of the staff present when speaking to the press.” A spokesperson for Reeves did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

It’s not surprising to see this sort of sexism, Campbell said, and it’s not unique to the GOP, to Mississippi or to reporters.

“Political reporting can be an old boys club, but I think this happens to a lot of women, in a lot of work arenas. That’s why it’s resonating right now,” she said.